2026-11-13 by Seung-Ho Kim

Fleece vs Cotton: 7 Fabric Order Mistakes and the Checklist That Prevents Them

Who this checklist is for

Any bulk fabric order over 500 meters should run through this sequence. It covers fleece, velvet, damask, performance textiles, and custom webbing — whether you're sourcing for a clothing line, a hotel refurbishment, or an industrial application.

I've been handling fabric sourcing at Outlast for nine years. In that time, I've personally made — and documented — 14 significant mistakes totaling roughly $23,000 in wasted budget. Wrong composition. Wrong dye lot. Wrong width assumption. Each one taught me a step that now lives on our team's pre-order checklist.

These steps aren't complicated. But skipping any one of them has cost me money — and in two cases, a client relationship. Seven steps. About 45 minutes. Here's the sequence.

The 7-step checklist

Step 1: Lock down composition — "fleece" is not a specification

In 2019, I ordered what I called "fleece" for a mid-weight jacket line. The supplier shipped 100% polyester polar fleece. Our design team had built the cost model around a cotton-poly blend. The fabric didn't take the dye the way our samples had. We had to re-order. $4,200 wasted, 11-day delay.

The lesson: "fleece" describes a knit construction, not a fiber. So does "cotton" — that's a fiber, not a structure. When someone asks about "fleece vs cotton," they're comparing a construction to a fiber. That's a category error. (I've seen this confusion in three vendor meetings since.) The same thing happens with denim. "Denim" is a twill weave, not a fiber. You can have cotton denim, poly denim, or stretch denim. The specs matter.

Our checklist now requires four things in writing:

  • Fiber content by percentage (e.g., 80% cotton / 20% polyester)
  • Construction type (knit, woven, non-woven)
  • Weight in GSM — not "mid-weight" or "heavy"
  • Finish (brushed, anti-pill, water-repellent, etc.)

Ask for a mill test report or certificate of analysis. If the supplier can't produce one, you're buying on faith. I've done that twice. Both times, the fiber content was off by 5–10%.

Step 2: Demand physical swatches for anything texture-dependent

Digital images lie. I learned this in 2021 when we approved a line of women's velvet coats based on a screen shot. The actual fabric had a 2mm pile crush that looked completely different under warehouse lighting. We sold through 60% of the run at full price and discounted the rest. Estimated margin loss: $3,800.

For velvet, damask, chenille, or anything where hand-feel matters: get an A4 physical swatch minimum. View it under both natural and fluorescent light. Crush a corner to see how the pile recovers.

For striped damask upholstery fabric, ask for a swatch that includes the full repeat. I once approved a stripe pattern from a partial swatch and discovered the repeat was 14 inches, not the 6 inches our cut plan assumed. That's a yield disaster hiding in a pretty pattern.

Step 3: Price at usable width, not "nominal" width

Most suppliers quote "width." What they mean varies. It could be selvedge-to-selvedge, usable width after trim, or print width. On one order of 1,800 meters of performance fabric, I priced based on a 150cm width. The actual usable width was 142cm. Our cut plan was off by 8cm per marker — about 120 extra meters needed. At $6.50/meter, that's $780 unplanned.

Here's the calculation: (required finished width × quantity) ÷ usable width = meters needed. Most people do this in their head. Don't. Write it down. At Outlast, we now price every order at usable width and confirm it in writing. The checklist line: "Confirm usable width in cm. Calculate yield at usable width, not nominal width."

Step 4: Control dye lots — and put the lot number on the PO

Dye lot variation is the silent killer of upholstery projects. In Q1 2023, we shipped a hotel order of striped damask where the first 400 meters came from lot A and the balance from lot B. The stripe color shifted by maybe 2%. Under hotel lighting, it looked like two different fabrics. We re-upholstered 28 rooms. Cost: $6,100 plus an uncomfortable client conversation.

What we do now:

  • Require a single dye lot for the entire order
  • If the order exceeds one lot, require a pre-shipment side-by-side photo under neutral lighting
  • Write the confirmed lot number directly on the purchase order

We now include a dye lot clause in every upholstery contract: single lot or no order. It's non-negotiable. Most mills will accommodate single-lot requests before production starts. After? Not so much.

Step 5: Get shrinkage and care specs in writing — before pricing

I used to assume shrinkage was "standard." There's no standard. I've seen 100% cotton shrink anywhere from 3% to 9% depending on finish. On a 2,000-meter order for a home textile client, we didn't account for 6% shrinkage in the cut plan. The finished panels came up short. $2,400 in remakes.

The checklist items:

  • Shrinkage percentage (warp and weft, separately)
  • Test method (AATCC 135, ISO 6330, or equivalent)
  • Care instructions the fabric is rated for (machine wash warm? dry clean only?)
  • Whether the spec holds after 1 wash or 5

One more thing: shrinkage can vary between colors of the same fabric. Dark dyes often behave differently than light ones. If your order has multiple colors, get specs for each. And if the supplier can't name the test method, the number is a guess. A guess is worse than nothing.

Step 6: Agree on testing standards before the first meter is woven

This is the step most buyers skip. I did for years. Then a shipment of "performance" fabric failed a client's flammability requirement because the mill tested to a different standard than the one in our contract. The whole lot was quarantined. We ate the shipping cost and the delay.

You don't need to be a lab technician. You need to write down:

  • Which standard applies (e.g., ASTM D6413 for flame resistance, AATCC 8 for crocking)
  • Who pays for testing (usually the mill — but confirm)
  • What happens if the lot fails (replacement? refund? who eats shipping?)

The cost of a failed test after shipment is 10–20x the cost of testing before production. That's not a guess.

Step 7: Run a pre-production sample — even for repeat orders

We skipped this once on a repeat order because "nothing changed." Something had: the mill switched their yarn supplier. The hand-feel was noticeably rougher. We caught it on the first 50 meters of the bulk run — after we'd committed to the full 3,000 meters.

Now, every order gets a 2–3 meter pre-production sample that we approve in writing before bulk starts. It adds 5–7 days. It has saved us from at least three bad lots in the past 18 months. The sample also serves as a reference standard — if there's a dispute about quality later, you have a physical benchmark to compare against.

Common mistakes (and what to do instead)

A few patterns I see repeated — on our own team and with clients who send us specs:

  • Trusting the category name. "Fleece," "linen," "performance fabric" — these are marketing terms, not specs. Ask for numbers.
  • Pricing before yield math. The per-meter price means nothing until you know usable width and shrinkage.
  • Skipping the physical swatch for "simple" fabrics. Simple fabrics have dye lot issues too. Maybe more.
  • Assuming the mill's test report matches your client's requirement. They rarely do, unless you specified it.
  • Letting the PO be verbal. If the lot number, width, and test standard aren't on paper, they don't exist.
  • Assuming the first quote is the final price. Fabric pricing changes with volume, dye lots, and scheduling. Confirm the price is valid for your specific quantity and timeline.

Why this matters more now

Lead times have tightened. Clients expect faster turnarounds. That pressure pushes buyers to skip steps — and skipping steps is how $23,000 in mistakes happens.

The checklist takes about 45 minutes. The mistakes it prevents cost weeks and thousands of dollars. The math isn't complicated.

At Outlast, this checklist is now part of our standard order intake. Nine years in, I still run it before every bulk order — even the ones I'm sure about.

Especially the ones I'm sure about.

Seung-Ho Kim

Seung-Ho Kim is a nonwoven and engineered-web analyst covering spunbond, meltblown, SMS and SMMS structures, medical and hygiene coverstocks, filter media, needle-punched felt, and geotextiles. He uses ISO 9073-1 and ISO 9073-3 for basis mass and strip tensile properties, with ISO 10319 for applicable geosynthetic wide-width testing, while tracking thickness, air permeability, pore structure, liquid strike-through, wetback, elongation, and web uniformity. His technical guides help converters, hygiene producers, filtration teams, and civil buyers connect layer design, process control, end-use exposure, and measurable release criteria.